Disadvantages of radiometric dating

One problem with earth dating is that the original earth surface is assumed to have eroded long ago.

But assuming the earth was formed at the time of the rest of our solar system, then recovered moon rock and meteorites can also be used to estimate the age of the earth.

In other words, half of the radioactive isotope in a sample would have decayed to Nitrogen-14 (N-14) in just 5,730 years.

disadvantages of radiometric dating-59disadvantages of radiometric dating-30disadvantages of radiometric dating-69

This implies the earth is at least 20 million years old.

Astronomical cycles can also be used to measure relative age.

In some cases these astronomical cycles in rock appear to have been laid down over some 25 million years (and radiometric dating puts the absolute age of the rock at some 200 million years).

Dating Anomalies Here we outline a few dating methods or 'clocks' that present a dating anomaly when referenced to the widely accepted OE age of 4.6 billion years. At the outset we note C-14 cannot be used to directly date the earth for the simple reason that the unstable C-14 isotope has a half-life of just 5,730 years.

But YE scientists point out some anomalies in relation to C-14 and a very old earth.

For instance, measurable amounts of C-14 have been found in fossil material, such as coal (traditionally Carboniferous period c300 mya).

In fact, organic samples from every portion of the Phanerozoic record (spanning the last 500 million years on OE dating) show detectable amounts of C-14.

The implication is that this organic material was either contaminated by new C-14, or it was buried much more recently and OE dating methods are suspect.

Radioactive parent (P) atoms decay to stable daughter (D) atoms e.g.

the carbon isotope C-14 decays to nitrogen-14 and the uranium isotope U-235 decays to the lead isotope Pb-207.

Mathematically, P = Po exp(-lambda T), where lambda = the decay constant and T = the period of decay. a zero initial number of D atoms, where P(or D) = the current number of P(or D) atoms, it follows that the age of a rock or mineral is computed as T=(1/lambda)ln(1 D/P).

Tags: , ,